Skip to main content

Deciding on non-emergent surgery? Explore key questions to determine if surgery, such as joint replacement or rotator cuff repair, is the right choice for you.

Deciding whether to undergo non-emergent surgery — such as a joint replacement, rotator cuff repair, or meniscus repair — can be challenging. While you can minimize risks by choosing a surgeon based on outcomes and data from a trusted source like SurgeonCheck.com, it’s essential to recognize that some risk will always be involved.

Consider these questions to help determine if surgery is the right option for you:

  1. Are you in good health otherwise?
    Your overall health can significantly impact both the surgery and recovery process. If you’re in good health, you may be better equipped to handle surgery and recover more quickly.
  2. Will the procedure screen for serious diseases that would have greater risk to your health down the road?
    Some surgeries can help identify or prevent severe health issues in the future. Consider if the surgery might uncover or reduce the risk of conditions that could worsen over time if left untreated.
  3. Will this improve your quality of life or decrease your risk of future complications?
    Think about how the surgery could enhance your day-to-day life or reduce the risk of complications down the road. A successful procedure might alleviate pain, increase mobility, or improve long-term health outcomes.
  4. Have you tried alternatives to surgery like physical therapy for a considerable time period?
    Non-surgical options like physical therapy can sometimes provide relief without the risks associated with surgery. If you haven’t already, give these alternatives a fair trial before committing to surgery.
  5. Has a SurgeonCheck recommended surgeon said you need the surgery?  
    SurgeonCheck evaluates surgeons based on appropriateness, among other factors, so if one of their recommended surgeons advises surgery, it’s a good indication of necessity. A surgeon who recommends unnecessary procedures would not make the list.
  6. Will the surgery improve your quality of life?
    Reflect on how surgery will impact you personally. A procedure that significantly enhances your quality of life might be worth the associated risks, whereas a surgery with marginal benefits may not.
  7. Will simple changes in your lifestyle accomplish the same outcome as a successful surgery?
    Consider whether lifestyle adjustments, such as weight loss or physical activity, could achieve similar results. For instance, losing weight might relieve joint pain and potentially eliminate the need for surgery altogether. Similarly, improving posture and incorporating targeted exercises could alleviate chronic back pain, sometimes making a spinal surgery unnecessary.
  8. Do you have support to accommodate work, family, and life during the downtime required from your procedure?
    Recovery can disrupt your daily routine, so having a strong support system is essential. Ensure that you have help with work, family obligations, and other responsibilities during your recovery period.

Want to Find the Best Surgeon for Your Needs? 

Discover Verified Surgeons on SurgeonCheck

SurgeonCheck is your independent, unbiased surgeon scorecard. We shine an objective light on variation in surgical quality at the individual surgeon level to profoundly improve the lives of patients and reduce healthcare costs.

Head over to SurgeonCheck.com to access independent, data-driven recommendations and choose the best surgeon for your needs.

© 2024 SurgeonCheck, LLC. All Rights Reserved.